Luca Turin
Luca Turin (born November 20, 1953) is an Italian biophysicist, writer, and fragrance researcher. He is best known for reviving the vibrational theory of olfaction with a quantum-mechanical mechanism. Mechanism, evidence, and Peat-community context: Sense of smell.
| Luca Turin | |
|---|---|
| Born | 20 November 1953 (age 72), Beirut, Lebanon |
| Died | Living |
| Nationality | Italian-Argentinian |
| Education | University College London (PhD in Physiology and Biophysics, 1978) |
| Occupation | Biophysicist, writer, perfume expert |
| Known for | Vibrational theory of olfaction |
| Notable works | The Secret of Scent (2006)
Perfumes: The A-Z Guide (with Tania Sanchez, 2008) Subject of Chandler Burr's The Emperor of Scent (2003) |
| Website | https://lucaturin.substack.com/about |
Early life
[edit]Turin was born in Beirut, Lebanon, to Italian-Argentinian parents: his father, Duccio Turin, was an architect for the United Nations, including work as chief architect for Palestinian refugee camps, and his mother, Adela Turin, was an art historian and industrial designer who went on to found a children's publishing house and a feminist organization. The family's mobility gave him a nomadic, multilingual childhood spent across France, Italy, and Switzerland; as a child he was already fascinated by scent, systematically analyzing smells like thyme during family travels. He completed his French baccalauréat in 1970.
Education and career
[edit]- He studied physiology and biophysics at University College London (UCL), earning his Ph.D. in 1978 with a thesis on gap-junction-mediated intercellular communication in the early amphibian embryo.
- For ten years (1982-1992), he worked as a tenured staff member at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) in France, researching cell-to-cell electrical signaling.
- In 1988 he joined neuroscientist Henri Korn's laboratory at the Institut Pasteur. There, with colleague Nicole Ropert, he found significant anomalies -- mismatched distributions, duplicated traces, inconsistencies between figures and text -- in Korn's earlier published data on neurotransmitter release in goldfish Mauthner cells. In 1990 Turin formally accused Korn of data fabrication and requested a CNRS investigation; he was dismissed from CNRS later that year, and fought a prolonged legal battle over what he considered retaliation for whistleblowing. The case resurfaced publicly in 2007 when biophysicist Jacques Ninio independently published a statistical critique echoing Turin's findings, prompting a reopened CNRS probe; Nature covered the story, quoting Turin describing the data as "so obviously fudged." Korn denied fraud, and the reopened investigation reached no formal misconduct finding, hampered by limited access to raw data.[1] The episode steered Turin away from academic neuroscience toward industry and, eventually, independent olfaction research.
- He returned to UCL to serve as a lecturer in Biophysics from 1992 to 2000.
- In 2001, he became the Chief Technical Officer of Flexitral, a startup where he utilized his vibrational theories to design new fragrances and flavor molecules, until the company closed in 2010.
- He has also held research and visiting positions at the National Institutes of Health, MIT (working on a DARPA-funded electronic nose project), the Alexander Fleming Biomedical Sciences Research Center in Athens (2011-2013), and the University of Ulm; since 2020 he has been Professor of Physiology at the University of Buckingham Medical School.
Notable/unique
[edit]Turin is known for the vibrational theory of smell: olfactory receptors as biological spectroscopes using inelastic electron tunneling (IETS), not classic lock-and-key shape matching alone. His isotope-discrimination work (normal vs deuterated molecules) is the best-known experimental line; in double-blind trials, deuterated musks were distinguished from ordinary ones with high statistical significance. The theory remains contested: a 2015 PNAS study from Eric Block's laboratory tested receptor activation by deuterated odorants and found no support for vibrational selectivity, and critics have argued biological temperatures would thermalize the relevant vibrations past detectability.[2] Full mechanism and evidence: Sense of smell.
More recently he has studied general anesthesia through electron spin resonance in Drosophila, finding that anesthetics like xenon and chloroform produce measurable, reversible changes in free electron spins, and has investigated quantum-process hypotheses of consciousness with Christof Koch.
Ray Peat cited a Turin lecture directly as evidence that Turin's resonance-based theory of smell and drug action was a living continuation of Albert Szent-Györgyi's electronic view of the cell:
There's a recent lecture by, I think his name is, Luca Turin, a Google lecture on pharmacology, but it is showing the current vitality of that idea of Albert Szent-Gyorgyi.
Peat also summarized Turin's mechanism directly, framing it as electronic resonance between molecule and cell rather than shape-based "lock and key" binding:
Luca Turin, there are some lectures by him. He's a perfume expert, but his theory of psychoactive drugs, or of hormones and so on, as well as odor molecules, is based on the idea that it's an electronic resonance between the molecule and the cell that accounts for the specificity. He gives many examples in which molecules that resonate have the same smell or the same biological effect, despite having a different shape.
— Ray Peat[4]
For Ray Peat, Turin's olfaction work is a useful general model for how cells and organisms detect and respond to their environment, grouped with holography as an illustration of perception based on whole patterns rather than parts:
Luca Turin's studies of odors and chemical perception provide a good introduction to this view of the brain.
— Ray Peat[5]
Luca Turin's work on olfaction and pharmacology, the detection of and response to molecular resonance, should be a model for thinking about the way cells and organisms are.
— Ray Peat[6]
Death
[edit]Published works
[edit]- Parfums: Le Guide (1992, 1994)
- The Secret of Scent: Adventures in Perfume and the Science of Smell (2006)
- Perfumes: The A-Z Guide (2008, co-authored with Tania Sanchez)
- The Little Book of Perfumes: The Hundred Classics (2011)
- Folio Columns 2003-2014 (2015)
- He is also the central subject of Chandler Burr's 2003 biographical book, The Emperor of Scent.
Patents
[edit]See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ↑ "Testing a radical theory," Nature Neuroscience. 2004;7(4):315.
- ↑ Block E, Jang S, Matsunami H, et al. "Implausibility of the vibrational theory of olfaction," PNAS. 2015;112(21):E2766-E2774. PMID 25901328.
- ↑ Ask the Herb Doctor: Inflammation I, KMUD, 2011
- ↑ Politics & Science: Evolution, KMUD, 2015
- ↑ Intention, Learning, and Health, Ray Peat newsletter
- ↑ Receptors, Or Sensitive Substance, Ray Peat newsletter