Diagnosing symptoms

[edit]

Symptoms, temperature and pulse, appetite, regularity of bowel movements and urination, and the appearance of the tongue are generally the most useful health metrics on their own, enough to indicate what's going on and what to try next. Getting more data is good, but a lack of data is not a reason to delay change and progress.

Thyroid - Temperature and heart rate

[edit]

Oral or armpit temperature in the morning, before getting out of bed, should be around 98° F [36.6º C], and it should rise to 98.6° F [37.1º C] by mid-morning. […] Healthy populations have an average resting pulse rate of about 85 per minute.

Markers of health Ideal Waking After breakfast Afternoon
Temperature 98.6 - 99F 37.0° - 37.2°C ~97.8°F ~98.6°F Holding steady, no drop
Heart rate 85 - 90 BPM 75 - 90 bpm 75 - 90 bpm 75 - 90 bpm, staying steady rather than spiking

Before diving into diet and supplements, establish a baseline using the table above. Track daily averages and aim for steady rises, not single readings; post-meal temperature should rise if metabolism is healthy (fuel burning), and drops if stress hormones dominate instead.

Temperature

[edit]
  • Waking temperature: Take immediately upon waking, before getting up
  • After-breakfast temperature: Take 1 hour after breakfast
  • Afternoon temperature: Take again later in the day to catch stress-driven drops that a single midday reading can miss
  • Goal: Waking ~97.8°F, rising to ~98.6°F by midday, holding steady into the afternoon

At low temperature, nearly every metabolic process slows together: detoxification, enzyme activity and ATP production, cognition, immune function, and androgen production all decline as temperature drops.[1]

Checking your temperature when you wake up, then about an hour after breakfast, can give you an idea of your thyroid status. It should get up to about 98.5 by mid-morning.

Pulse

[edit]

"If it's from your basic metabolism, it will stay close to that all day while sitting."

Warning signs of adrenaline-driven pulse

[edit]

A high pulse with cold hands, anxiety, or inability to sit still often indicates adrenaline compensation for low thyroid, not true high metabolism. See also Body markersExtremities below, cold hands and feet are the same adrenaline signal viewed as a body marker.

List of blood tests

[edit]

Marek online blood test

Idealabs steroid analysis

Marker Male Female
Prolactin in men 4-7 ng/ml (85–150 mU/L) female 1-12 ng/ml
Total Cholesterol 160 - 200 mg/dl
RT3 No fixed target; stress-induced cortisol raises the deiodinase that produces inactive RT3, worsened by low-sugar diets[2]
CRP No fixed target; elevated CRP tracks with low FT4, low cholesterol, and low vitamin D/K status[3]
TSH Below 1, as close to 0 as possible
PTH 15 pg/ml
CO2 30 mmol/l
Serum calcium 9 mg/dl
Serum phosphate 3 mg/dl

Also worth including: estrogen, vitamin D, a liver panel, and an iron panel. A GI-map stool test can directly identify gut pathogens, dysbiosis, and digestive function markers.


Blood panel tool (beta)

[edit]

Compare a few lab numbers to educational targets used on this site. Take results from the widget with a grain of salt, it's approximate and unfinished, the goal is to point you to primary sources with quotes that pop up below based on your results. Prefer temperature and pulse first (Tracking). See your results plotted on the Pathway map. Full page: Blood panel.

Buteyko CP and sleep quality

[edit]

Buteyko control pause (breath-hold time after a normal exhale) and sleep quality are also useful day-to-day metrics, alongside temperature, pulse, and the markers above.

Self tracking

[edit]

Record waking and after-breakfast temperature and pulse, appetite, and energy in the quick form; sleep, food, and supplements are under "More fields." Entries save to your private log (permanent account required).

Manual sheet

Prefer a spreadsheet, or on a shared device? Use the "Download blank CSV template" button below the charts to get an empty copy of this table's columns as a CSV file, ready to open in Excel, Google Sheets, or Numbers. It's offered as a download rather than shown inline here since the full table is too wide for the page to display cleanly.

Digestion

[edit]

Bristol stool chart

[edit]
Type 1 Bristol stool chart Type 1: separate hard lumps, like nuts Separate hard lumps, like nuts (hard to pass)
Type 2 Bristol stool chart Type 2: sausage-shaped but lumpy Sausage-shaped but lumpy
Type 3 Bristol stool chart Type 3: like a sausage but with cracks on its surface Like a sausage but with cracks on its surface
Type 4 Bristol stool chart Type 4: like a sausage or snake, smooth and soft Like a sausage or snake, smooth and soft
Type 5 Bristol stool chart Type 5: soft blobs with clear-cut edges Soft blobs with clear-cut edges (passed easily)
Type 6 Bristol stool chart Type 6: fluffy pieces with ragged edges, a mushy stool Fluffy pieces with ragged edges, a mushy stool
Type 7 Bristol stool chart Type 7: watery, no solid pieces Watery, no solid pieces - entirely liquid

Quick bowel movements two to four times a day is generally what is good to aim for.[4] See also Body markersBowel movements below.

Transit-time check

[edit]

Eat a portion of visibly identifiable food, whole corn kernels or grated carrot work well, and time how long it takes to appear in the stool. This gives a rough estimate of gut transit time.

Urine quality chart

[edit]
Number Color Status What it means Action
1 Hydrated Pale, odourless and plentiful urine usually means that you are well hydrated. Keep drinking at the same rate.
2
3 Mildly dehydrated Slightly darker yellow urine usually means that you need to drink more water. Drink a glass of water now.
4
5 Dehydrated Medium-dark yellow urine usually means that you are dehydrated. Drink 2-3 glasses of water now.
6
7 Very dehydrated Darker, strong-smelling urine in small amounts can be a sign of dehydration. Drink a large bottle of water immediately.
8
9 Hospital Blood Call 9/11 now

Foamy urine is a sign of increased circulation of fatty acids, which is most common after stress. In rare cases, foamy urine may be a sign of kidney issues.[5] See also Body markersUrination below.

What to drink

[edit]

Ray Peat's own rule of thumb is simple:

In general, it's best to drink water only when you're thirsty.

Not all fluids hydrate equally. A controlled trial measured how much of a 1 L drink stayed in the body 2 hours later versus being urinated out, as a "beverage hydration index" relative to plain water (=1.0). Whole and skim milk, and an oral rehydration solution, retained fluid best (index around 1.5), likely because the protein, fat, and electrolytes slow gastric emptying and reduce urine output; orange juice also did significantly better than water (around 1.4). Cola, tea, coffee, beer, sports drinks, and sparkling water were all statistically indistinguishable from plain water in the same trial, despite the popular claim that they hydrate better.[7]

Bar chart of Beverage Hydration Index at 2 hours for 13 drinks vs still water, sorted lowest to highest: coffee and lager below water, sparkling water and still water near 1.0, orange juice/full-fat milk/ORS/skimmed milk highest

* = significantly higher than water (p<0.05), ** = p<0.01. ORS = oral rehydration solution. Exact BHI values are only published in the paper's text for still water, orange juice (1.40), full-fat milk (1.50), ORS (1.54), and skimmed milk (1.58); the rest (sparkling water, cola, diet cola, sports drink, lager, coffee, tea, cold tea) are read off Figure 2's bar chart, since no results table lists them numerically. Lager sits below water (alcohol's diuretic effect offsets its energy density, per the paper's discussion), not tied with it. Chart data from Maughan et al. 2016. Water quality matters more than the distilled-vs-mineral question people often worry about; good mineral content mostly reflects sunlight and soil conditions, not something to fear from soft or distilled water.[8] Municipal tap water's fluoridation and chlorination are the more relevant quality concerns, see Fluoride.

Urine RMR test

[edit]

For every 1000kcal burned, a liter of water is used. If you discard the morning urine, and collect the urine for the rest of the day while measuring your water intake, you can calculate your resting metabolic rate.[9]

(water intake - urine volume) * 1000 = RMR

Body markers

[edit]

If your hands are warm and you feel kind and energetic, you’re doing it right. If you’re cold and cranky, something is wrong

Tongue

[edit]

Ideal

  • Should be pink, smooth

Symptoms

  • White coating, especially on the back/middle of the tongue = bacterial overgrowth, SIBO or Candida
  • Cracks = likely a nutrient deficiency

Nails and Fingers

[edit]

Ideal

  • Fast-growing
  • Nailbeds should be pink
    • means tissue is retaining CO2

Symptoms

Toenails are a more reliable sample than hair for assessing mineral status. Hair quickly absorbs minerals like copper and calcium from water/plumbing during washing, skewing results, while toenails better represent actual body composition.[10]

Eyebrows

[edit]

Ideal

  • Full

Symptoms

  • Queen Anne's sign = Thinning or loss of the outer third of the eyebrows is one of the physical manifestations of hypothyroidism[11]

Eyes

[edit]

Ideal

  • Focused, calm and alert

Symptoms

  • Eye bags = Low thyroid, gut irritation, tired
  • Bulging = Grave's disease, (easily misdiagnosed as hyperthyroidism)
  • Enlarged eye vessels, esp. yellow around = vitamin B deficiency, mainly B2; eating liver once a week can help[12]
  • Dark circles under the eyes = vitamin C status + impaired collagen production, oxidative stress
  • Dry = Hashimotos[13]

Hair

[edit]

Ideal

  • Full head of hair

Symptoms

  • Thinning/norwood = high prolactin and everything
  • Premature graying = often reported alongside other low-thyroid signs

Earlobe

[edit]

Ideal

  • Smooth

Symptoms

  • Crease = heart disease or circulatory disorder

Face skin

[edit]

Ideal

  • Baby

Symptoms

Lips

[edit]

Ideal

  • Kissable

Symptoms

Teeth

[edit]

Ideal

  • Solid, opaque edges

Symptoms

  • Decay, or edges becoming transparent = often reported alongside other low-metabolism signs

Body skin

[edit]

Ideal

  • Smooth, elastic, without spots

Symptoms

Veins

[edit]

Ideal

  • Smooth, elastic, without spots

Symptoms

  • Bulging veins = high estrogen, especially on the back of the hand

Women's breasts

[edit]

Ideal

  • Firm, perky

Symptoms

  • Tender = high estrogen
  • Sagging = low connective-tissue tone from a metabolic energy problem, typically accumulated PUFA[15]

Men's chest

[edit]

Ideal

  • Developed like a man's

Symptoms

Extremities

[edit]

Ideal

  • Warm, circulated

Symptoms

Sweat glands

[edit]

Ideal

  • Moderate amount, non-stinky

Symptoms

Nose

[edit]

Ideal

  • Reasonably dry

Symptoms

Posture

[edit]

Ideal

  • Straight, non tense

Symptoms

Tummy

[edit]

Ideal

  • Flat(ish)

Symptoms

  • Bulging gut = high HGH, general SIBO
    • Could also be visceral fat accumulation or weak abdomenal muscles/PSOAs

Movement

[edit]

Ideal

  • Normal, balanced, free-flowing

Symptoms

  • Movement disorders, twitches = high serotonin

Energy levels

[edit]

Ideal

Symptoms

  • Fatigue = low T3

Bowel movements

[edit]

Ideal

Symptoms

Urination

[edit]

Ideal

  • sparse, only during waking, clear color

Symptoms

Appetite

[edit]

Ideal

  • Healthy

Symptoms

Voice

[edit]

Ideal

  • Clear, steady, no hoarseness

Symptoms

Cravings

[edit]

Acidic/sour

[edit]
  • your body needs more sodium
  • Aldosterone imbalance
  • Premenstrual shift
    • Commonly trigger pickle cravings in women. Hypothyroid women especially suffer from both sugar and salt cravings premenstrually.
  • Thyroid function
    • Aging lowers your thyroid function, and your thyroid deficiency causes you to lose sodium. So the craving in most people is a very biological thing. But you could correct it by correcting your thyroid function, which makes you retain salt efficiently so you don't need to eat so much
  • The manganese connection
    • Blood test of pregnant women with pickle cravings showed manganese deficiency.

Sweet

[edit]

Sugar craving is usually a sign of a genuine need for sugar, commonly from hypothyroidism rather than an "addiction" in the moralistic sense.[17]

Salty

[edit]

Salt restriction itself raises adrenaline and disrupts sleep. Salting food normalizes adrenaline and improves sleep, on top of the sodium-loss mechanisms above.[18]

Sparkling water/soda

[edit]

Carbonated water raises body CO2, improving oxygen delivery to tissue via the Bohr effect and promoting vasodilation.[19]

Achilles reflex speed

[edit]

Ideal

  • Fast relaxation phase (film yourself dropping foot)

Symptoms

  • Slow/hanging reflex

Broda Barnes chart of common hypothyroidism symptoms

[edit]

Broda Barnes chart[20]

Symptom % prevalence in hypothyroidism
Weakness 98.5
Sensation of cold 92
Dry skin 88
Lethargy 88
Edema of eyelids 88
Edema of face 87
Coarse skin 83.5
Cold skin 81.5
Decreased sweating 78.5
Coarseness of hair 75.5
Slow speech 73.5
Slow movements 73
Thick tongue 71
Heart enlargement 68
Gain in weight 67.5
Impaired memory 65.5
Labored or difficult breathing 63.5
Hoarseness 63
Muscle weakness 61
Depression 60
Pallor of skin 58.5
Constipation 57.5
Swelling of feet 56
Burning or tingling sensations 56
Pallor of lips 53.5
Loss of hair 49
Slowing of mental activity 49
Nervousness 43
Loss of appetite 42.5
Brittle nails 41
Muscle pain 36
Deafness 35
Excessive menstruation 32.5
Poor heart sounds 30
Joint pain 29
Palpitations 27
Poor vision 24
Pain over the heart 20.5
Changes in back of eye 20
Painful menstruation 18
Loss of weight 11
Emotional instability 11
Choking sensation 9
Fineness of hair 9
Cyanosis (bluish skin) 9
Difficulty in swallowing 3
Heat intolerance 2

Iodine deficiency

[edit]

"The skin test of iodine deficiency is completely unscientific. Iodine is converted to colorless iodide by reductants, including vitamin C, glutathione, and thiosulphate... The test is completely irrational. It implies that the body should be saturated with iodine.” - Ray Peat

Excessive amounts of iodide have been linked to the development of autoimmune thyroiditis in humans and animals[21]

Food intolerance

[edit]

DIY Food Allergy Test

[edit]
  1. Before suspected allergenic meal, relax consciously and check resting pulse rate
  2. Eat slowly, calmly
  3. Wait 10 mins and check pulse again If BPM increases by
    • <10, unlikely
    • ~10-14, possibly
    • >15, likely
  4. Eliminate suspected food and repeat until +ID
Why do a food allergy test?
[edit]

If you have symptoms of chronic inflammation:

  • Runny/stuffy nose
  • Excess mucous/saliva
  • Red/crusty eyes
  • Itchy ears
  • Brain fog/Headaches
  • Myalgia/Neuralgia
  • etc.

Rule out food allergies before moving onto expensive mycotoxin/heavy metal etc. testing[22]


Testing response to specific foods and supplements

[edit]

Trying specific foods or supplements one at a time and noting a positive or negative reaction can point to a specific underlying issue:

Philosophy of testing

[edit]

Testing will always be imperfect relative to overall function; the body is not a machine. Tracking data is less about hitting specific values than about creating progress in life and repeatable symptom relief.

When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.

— Charles Goodhart

Health is not a means to an end.

Roadmap Navigation
Previous step
Roadmap/01 - Basics
← Full Roadmap Overview Next step
Roadmap/03 - Diet

References

[edit]
  1. @TakeThiamine, X post (secondary synthesis, not a primary source).
  2. Ray Peat, email correspondence, "Thyroid," raypeatemails.com, https://raypeatemails.com/Topics/Thyroid
  3. Haidut, "Low thyroid, cholesterol, vitamin D/K linked to depression and suicide," haidut.me (forum synthesis, not a primary source).
  4. "Bristol Stool Chart," Continence Health Australia.
  5. "Urine colour chart," NSW Health.
  6. Ray Peat, email correspondence, "Distilled Water," raypeatemails.com.
  7. Maughan RJ, et al., "A randomized trial to assess the potential of different beverages to affect hydration status: development of a beverage hydration index," Am J Clin Nutr. 2016;103(3):717-723. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26702122/#:~:text=Clin%20Nutr%20Actions%20Search%20in%20PubMed%20Search%20in
  8. Ray Peat, email correspondence, "Distilled Water," raypeatemails.com.
  9. Ray Peat, "Hypothyroidism," raypeat.com.
  10. Ray Peat, quoted in Haidut, "Idealabs Service—Mineral Analysis (Hair and/or (Toe)nail)," Ray Peat Forum.
  11. Taguchi H, Nishioka H. "Eyebrow loss and the Queen Anne sign in hypothyroidism," QJM. 2023. PMID 37449890.
  12. Ray Peat, email correspondence, "Eyes," raypeatemails.com.
  13. @lowmegatron, X post (secondary synthesis, not a primary source).
  14. @Outdoctrination, X post (secondary synthesis, not a primary source).
  15. Ray Peat, email Q&A on aspirin, pregnenolone, and connective tissue.
  16. Rao ID, et al., "Voice Characteristics in Patients with Thyroid Disorders," J Clin Diagn Res. 2019;13(6). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6592446/#:~:text=diagnosis%20was%20made%20and%20six%20months%20later
  17. Ray Peat, email correspondence, "Sugar," raypeatemails.com, https://raypeatemails.com/Topics/Sugar
  18. Ray Peat's Newsletter, "When Energy Fails: Edema, Heart Failure..."
  19. Ray Peat, "Energy, Structure, and Carbon Dioxide: A Realistic View of the Role of CO2 in Respiration and Metabolism," Ray Peat Newsletter, 2013.
  20. Hypothyroidism: The unsuspected illness’ by Dr. Broda Barnes, M.D.
  21. Luo Y, et al. "Iodine excess as an environmental risk factor for autoimmune thyroid disease," Int J Mol Sci. 2014. PMID 25050783.
  22. @RayPeatHeadShop, X post (secondary synthesis, not a primary source).